Robert S. Paton

Find an error

Name:
Organization: University of Oxford , England
Department: Chemistry Research Laboratory
Title: Professor(PhD)

TOPICS

Co-reporter:Yifei Li, Kelvin E. Jackson, Andrew Charlton, Ben Le Neve-Foster, Asma Khurshid, Heinrich-K. A. Rudy, Amber L. Thompson, Robert S. Paton, and David. M. Hodgson
The Journal of Organic Chemistry October 6, 2017 Volume 82(Issue 19) pp:10479-10479
Publication Date(Web):September 27, 2017
DOI:10.1021/acs.joc.7b01954
Quantum chemical studies of C-ethylation of 1-methyl- and 1,4,4-trimethyl-tropane-derived enamines predict good (89:11 er, B3LYP) and high (98:2 er, B3LYP) levels, respectively, of asymmetric induction in the resulting α-alkylated aldehydes. The nonracemic tropanes were synthesized using Mannich cyclization strategies (Robinson-Schöpf and by way of a Davis-type N-sulfinyl amino bisketal, respectively), and ethylation of the derived enamines was found to support the predicted sense and magnitude of asymmetric induction (81:19 er and 95:5 er, respectively). A comparison of several computational methods highlights the robustness of predicted trends in enantioselectivity, enabling theory to guide synthesis.
Co-reporter:Fernanda Duarte and Robert S. Paton
Journal of the American Chemical Society July 5, 2017 Volume 139(Issue 26) pp:8886-8886
Publication Date(Web):June 5, 2017
DOI:10.1021/jacs.7b02468
We describe the first theoretical study of a landmark example of chiral anion phase-transfer catalysis: the enantioselective ring-opening of meso-aziridinium and episulfonium cations promoted by asymmetric counteranion-directed catalysis (ACDC). The mechanism of ion-pairing, ring-opening, and catalyst deactivation have been studied in the condensed phase with both classical and quantum methods using explicitly and implicitly solvated models. We find that the stability of chiral ion-pairs, a prerequisite for asymmetric catalysis, is dominated by electrostatic interactions at long range and by CH···O interactions at short range. The decisive role of solvent upon ion-pair formation and of nonbonding interactions upon enantioselectivity are quantified by complementary computational approaches. The major enantiomer is favored by a smaller distortion of the substrate, demonstrated by a distortion/interaction analysis. Our computational results rationalize the stereoselectivity for several experimental results and demonstrate a combined classical/quantum approach to perform realistic modeling of chiral counterion catalysis in solution.
Co-reporter:Aroonroj Mekareeya, P. Ross Walker, Almudena Couce-Rios, Craig D. Campbell, Alan Steven, Robert S. Paton, and Edward A. Anderson
Journal of the American Chemical Society July 26, 2017 Volume 139(Issue 29) pp:10104-10104
Publication Date(Web):July 12, 2017
DOI:10.1021/jacs.7b05436
The cycloisomerization of enynes catalyzed by Pd(OAc)2 and bis-benzylidene ethylenediamine (bbeda) is a landmark methodology in transition-metal-catalyzed cycloisomerization. However, the mechanistic pathway by which this reaction proceeds has remained unclear for several decades. Here we describe mechanistic investigations into this reaction using enynamides, which deliver azacycles with high regio- and stereocontrol. Extensive 1H NMR spectroscopic studies and isotope effects support a palladium(II) hydride-mediated pathway and reveal crucial roles of bbeda, water, and the precise nature of the Pd(OAc)2 pre-catalyst. Computational studies support these mechanistic findings and lead to a clear picture of the origins of the high stereocontrol that can be achieved in this transformation, as well as suggesting a novel mechanism by which hydrometalation proceeds.
Co-reporter:Luis Simón and Robert S. Paton
The Journal of Organic Chemistry April 7, 2017 Volume 82(Issue 7) pp:3855-3855
Publication Date(Web):March 16, 2017
DOI:10.1021/acs.joc.7b00540
An ONIOM(QM/MM) study on the mechanism of the Michael addition to triple bonds catalyzed by chiral diiminophosphorane catalysts has been performed to understand the stereoselectivity of the product olefin. Our results are consistent with the experimental enantioselectivity, but more importantly, reveal that the Z vs E preference depends on the influence of the catalyst upon the geometry of the allenyl enolate formed in the addition step. These intermediates show an innate preference for a (Z)-configuration, although this can be suppressed by steric interactions due to a catalyst. This leads to two distinct mechanisms in which the kinetic basis for (E) or (Z)-stereoselectivity is determined by a different step. Bifunctional iminophosphorane catalysts are found to use steric interactions to override innate stereoelectronic effects of the allenyl enolate reactive intermediate.
Co-reporter:Tiffany Piou, Fedor Romanov-Michailidis, Maria Romanova-Michaelides, Kelvin E. Jackson, Natthawat Semakul, Trevor D. Taggart, Brian S. Newell, Christopher D. Rithner, Robert S. PatonTomislav Rovis
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2017 Volume 139(Issue 3) pp:1296-1310
Publication Date(Web):January 6, 2017
DOI:10.1021/jacs.6b11670
CpXRh(III)-catalyzed C–H functionalization reactions are a proven method for the efficient assembly of small molecules. However, rationalization of the effects of cyclopentadienyl (CpX) ligand structure on reaction rate and selectivity has been viewed as a black box, and a truly systematic study is lacking. Consequently, predicting the outcomes of these reactions is challenging because subtle variations in ligand structure can cause notable changes in reaction behavior. A predictive tool is, nonetheless, of considerable value to the community as it would greatly accelerate reaction development. Designing a data set in which the steric and electronic properties of the CpXRh(III) catalysts were systematically varied allowed us to apply multivariate linear regression algorithms to establish correlations between these catalyst-based descriptors and the regio-, diastereoselectivity, and rate of model reactions. This, in turn, led to the development of quantitative predictive models that describe catalyst performance. Our newly described cone angles and Sterimol parameters for CpX ligands served as highly correlative steric descriptors in the regression models. Through rational design of training and validation sets, key diastereoselectivity outliers were identified. Computations reveal the origins of the outstanding stereoinduction displayed by these outliers. The results are consistent with partial η5–η3 ligand slippage that occurs in the transition state of the selectivity-determining step. In addition to the instructive value of our study, we believe that the insights gained are transposable to other group 9 transition metals and pave the way toward rational design of C–H functionalization catalysts.
Co-reporter:Natthawat Semakul;Kelvin E. Jackson;Tomislav Rovis
Chemical Science (2010-Present) 2017 vol. 8(Issue 2) pp:1015-1020
Publication Date(Web):2017/01/30
DOI:10.1039/C6SC02587K
The diastereoselective coupling of O-substituted arylhydroxamates and cyclopropenes mediated by Rh(III) catalysis was successfully developed. Through ligand development, the diastereoselectivity of this reaction was improved using a heptamethylindenyl (Ind*) ligand, which has been rationalized using quantum chemical calculations. In addition, the nature of the O-substituted ester of benzhydroxamic acid proved important for high diastereoselectivity. This transformation tolerates a variety of benzamides and cyclopropenes that furnish cyclopropa[c]dihydroisoquinolones with high diastereocontrol, which could then be easily transformed into synthetically useful building blocks for pharmaceuticals and bio-active molecules.
Co-reporter:Dr. Rubén Manzano;Dr. Swarup Datta; Dr. Robert S. Paton; Dr. Darren J. Dixon
Angewandte Chemie 2017 Volume 129(Issue 21) pp:5928-5932
Publication Date(Web):2017/05/15
DOI:10.1002/ange.201612048
AbstractA silver(I) and amine co-catalyzed desymmetrization of 4-propargylamino cyclohexanones for the direct enantioselective synthesis of 2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonanes is described. Exploiting reactivity arising from dual activation of the pendant terminal alkyne by silver(I) and the ketone moiety through transient enamine formation, this synthetically relevant transformation is easy to perform, efficient and broad in scope. High enantioselectivity (up to 96 % ee) was achieved by exploiting a significant matching effect between the chirality of a cinchona alkaloid-derived aminophosphine ligand for the silver(I) salt and the 2-bis(aryl)methylpyrrolidine catalyst which was rationalized by DFT calculations. This allowed for the preparation of both enantiomers of the bicyclic product with near-identical stereocontrol.
Co-reporter:Dr. Rubén Manzano;Dr. Swarup Datta; Dr. Robert S. Paton; Dr. Darren J. Dixon
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2017 Volume 56(Issue 21) pp:5834-5838
Publication Date(Web):2017/05/15
DOI:10.1002/anie.201612048
AbstractA silver(I) and amine co-catalyzed desymmetrization of 4-propargylamino cyclohexanones for the direct enantioselective synthesis of 2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonanes is described. Exploiting reactivity arising from dual activation of the pendant terminal alkyne by silver(I) and the ketone moiety through transient enamine formation, this synthetically relevant transformation is easy to perform, efficient and broad in scope. High enantioselectivity (up to 96 % ee) was achieved by exploiting a significant matching effect between the chirality of a cinchona alkaloid-derived aminophosphine ligand for the silver(I) salt and the 2-bis(aryl)methylpyrrolidine catalyst which was rationalized by DFT calculations. This allowed for the preparation of both enantiomers of the bicyclic product with near-identical stereocontrol.
Co-reporter:Qian Peng and Robert S. Paton
Accounts of Chemical Research 2016 Volume 49(Issue 5) pp:1042
Publication Date(Web):May 3, 2016
DOI:10.1021/acs.accounts.6b00084
This Account describes the use of quantum-chemical calculations to elucidate mechanisms and develop catalysts to accomplish highly selective cyclization reactions. Chemistry is awash with cyclic molecules, and the creation of rings is central to organic synthesis. Cyclization reactions, the formation of rings by the reaction of two ends of a linear precursor, have been instrumental in the development of predictive models for chemical reactivity, from Baldwin’s classification and rules for ring closure to the Woodward and Hoffmann rules based on the conservation of orbital symmetry and beyond. Ring formation provides a productive and fertile testing ground for the exploration of catalytic mechanisms and chemo-, regio-, diastereo-, and enantioselectivity using computational and experimental approaches. This Account is organized around case studies from our laboratory and illustrates the ways in which computations provide a deeper understanding of the mechanisms of catalysis in 5-endo cyclizations and how computational predictions can lead to the development of new catalysts for enhanced stereoselectivities in asymmetric cycloisomerizations.We have explored the extent to which several cation-directed 5-endo ring-closing reactions may be considered as electrocyclic and demonstrated that reaction pathways and magnetic parameters of transition structures computed using quantum chemistry are inconsistent with this notion, instead favoring a polar mechanism. A rare example of selectivity in favor of 5-endo-trig ring closure is shown to result from subtle substrate effects that bias the reactant conformation out-of-plane, limiting the involvement of cyclic conjugation. The mode of action of a chiral ammonium counterion was deduced via conformational sampling of the transition state assembly and involves coordination to the substrate via a series of nonclassical hydrogen bonds. We describe how computational mechanistic understanding has led directly to the discovery of new catalyst structures for enantioselective cycloisomerizations. Calculations have revealed that stepwise C–C bond formation and proton transfer dictate the exclusive endo diastereoselectivity of the intramolecular Michael addition to form 2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane skeletons catalyzed by primary amines. These insights have led to development of a highly enantioselective catalyst with higher atom economy than previous generations.This Account also explores transition-metal-catalyzed cycloisomerizations, where our theoretical investigations have uncovered an unexpected reaction pathway in the [5 + 2] cycloisomerization of ynamides. This has led to the design of new phosphoramidite ligands to enable double-stereodifferentiating cycloisomerizations in both matched and mismatched catalyst–substrate settings. Computational understanding of the factors responsible for the regio-, enantio-, and diasterocontrol is shown to generate tangible predictions leading to an acceleration of catalyst development for selective cyclizations.
Co-reporter:Arghya Deb, Avijit Hazra, Qian Peng, Robert S. PatonDebabrata Maiti
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2016 Volume 139(Issue 2) pp:763-775
Publication Date(Web):December 20, 2016
DOI:10.1021/jacs.6b10309
Directing group-assisted regioselective C–H olefination with electronically biased olefins is well studied. However, the incorporation of unactivated olefins has remained largely unsuccessful. A proper mechanistic understanding of olefination involving unactivated alkenes is therefore essential for enhancing their usage in future. In this Article, detailed experimental and computational mechanistic studies on palladium catalyzed C–H olefination with unactivated, aliphatic alkenes are described. The isolation of Pd(II) intermediates is shown to be effective for elucidating the elementary steps involved in catalytic olefination. Reaction rate and order determination, control experiments, isotopic labeling studies, and Hammett analysis have been used to understand the reaction mechanism. The results from these experimental studies implicate β-hydride elimination as the rate-determining step and that a mechanistic switch occurs between cationic and neutral pathway. Computational studies support this interpretation of the experimental evidence and are used to uncover the origins of selectivity.
Co-reporter:Luis Simón and Robert S. Paton  
Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry 2016 vol. 14(Issue 11) pp:3031-3039
Publication Date(Web):26 Jan 2016
DOI:10.1039/C6OB00045B
The mechanism for the spiroacetalization of enol-ethers 1 and 2 promoted by chiral phosphoric acid (CPA) catalyst (I) and by chiral imidodiphosphoric acid catalyst (II) has been investigated by QM/MM methods. The computed levels of enantioselectivity following exhaustive conformational analysis is in close agreement with the sense and magnitude of experimental results. Small substrates fit inside catalyst I to yield both enantiomers, in agreement with the absence of asymmetric induction for this reaction, while for catalyst II chiral discrimination between TS structures is possible. Unlike reactions catalysed by CPA or CPA derivatives in which steric effects and substrate distortion controls enantioselectivity, we show that chiral discrimination results from the restricted area and direction of possible hydrogen-bonding interactions with a more confined catalyst structure.
Co-reporter:Wilian Augusto Cortopassi, Kiran Kumar, Fernanda Duarte, Andre Silva Pimentel, Robert S. Paton
Journal of Molecular Graphics and Modelling 2016 Volume 67() pp:69-84
Publication Date(Web):June 2016
DOI:10.1016/j.jmgm.2016.04.011
•Overview of epigenetic writing, erasing and reading mechanisms from a chemical perspective.•Computational modelling is effective for understanding the molecular basis of selectivity and activity of these processes.•QM/MM with the inclusion of dispersion corrections is an efficient approach for determining accurate energetics.•Long time MD simulations are necessary to describe conformational changes involved in substrate binding.•Energy decomposition analysis (EDA) is a powerful tool for quantifying protein interactions on histone modifying/reading mechanisms.Epigenetic pathways are involved in a wide range of diseases, including cancer and neurological disorders. Specifically, histone modifying and reading processes are the most broadly studied and are targeted by several licensed drugs. Although there have been significant advances in understanding the mechanistic aspects underlying epigenetic regulation, the development of selective small-molecule inhibitors remains a challenge.Experimentally, it is generally difficult to elucidate the atomistic basis for substrate recognition, as well as the sequence of events involved in binding and the subsequent chemical processes. In this regard, computational modelling is particularly valuable, since it can provide structural features (including transition state structures along with kinetic and thermodynamic parameters) that enable both qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the mechanistic details involved. Here, we summarize knowledge gained from computational modelling studies elucidating the role of the protein environment in histone-lysine modifying and reading mechanisms. We give a perspective on the importance of calculations to aid and advance the understanding of these processes and for the future development of selective inhibitors for epigenetic regulators.A tryptophan cage is important for methylated lysine recognition by PHD fingers.
Co-reporter:Wilian A. Cortopassi;Robert Simion;Charles E. Honsby; Tanos C. C. França; Robert S. Paton
Chemistry - A European Journal 2015 Volume 21( Issue 52) pp:18983-18992
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201502983

Abstract

JMJD2A catalyses the demethylation of di- and trimethylated lysine residues in histone tails and is a target for the development of new anticancer medicines. Mechanistic details of demethylation are yet to be elucidated and are important for the understanding of epigenetic processes. We have evaluated the initial step of histone demethylation by JMJD2A and demonstrate the dramatic effect of the protein environment upon oxygen binding using quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations. The changes in electronic structure have been studied for possible spin states and different conformations of O2, using a combination of quantum and classical simulations. O2 binding to this histone demethylase is computed to occur preferentially as an end-on superoxo radical bound to a high-spin ferric centre, yielding an overall quintet ground state. The favourability of binding is strongly influenced by the surrounding protein: we have quantified this effect using an energy decomposition scheme into electrostatic and dispersion contributions. His182 and the methylated lysine assist while Glu184 and the oxoglutarate cofactor are deleterious for O2 binding. Charge separation in the superoxo-intermediate benefits from the electrostatic stabilization provided by the surrounding residues, stabilizing the binding process significantly. This work demonstrates the importance of the extended protein environment in oxygen binding, and the role of energy decomposition in understanding the physical origin of binding/recognition.

Co-reporter:Wilian A. Cortopassi;Robert Simion;Charles E. Honsby; Tanos C. C. França; Robert S. Paton
Chemistry - A European Journal 2015 Volume 21( Issue 52) pp:
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201504536

Abstract

Invited for the cover of this issue is the group of Robert S. Paton at the University of Oxford and his collaborators from Brazil and the Czech Republic. The image depicts histone–enzyme complexation and the chemical interactions inside the active site that define the mode of action. Read the full text of the article at 10.1002/chem.201502983.

Co-reporter:Adam D. GammackYamagata;Dr. Swarup Datta;Kelvin E. Jackson;Linus Stegbauer;Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Darren J. Dixon
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2015 Volume 54( Issue 16) pp:4899-4903
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/anie.201411924

Abstract

A new catalytic asymmetric desymmetrization reaction for the synthesis of enantioenriched derivatives of 2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane, a key motif common to many alkaloids, has been developed. Employing a cyclohexanediamine-derived primary amine organocatalyst, a range of prochiral cyclohexanone derivatives possessing an α,β-unsaturated ester moiety linked to the 4-position afforded the bicyclic products, which possess three stereogenic centers, as single diastereoisomers in high enantioselectivity (83–99 % ee) and in good yields (60–90 %). Calculations revealed that stepwise CC bond formation and proton transfer via a chair-shaped transition state dictate the exclusive endo selectivity and enabled the development of a highly enantioselective primary amine catalyst.

Co-reporter:Adam D. GammackYamagata;Dr. Swarup Datta;Kelvin E. Jackson;Linus Stegbauer;Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Darren J. Dixon
Angewandte Chemie 2015 Volume 127( Issue 16) pp:4981-4985
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/ange.201411924

Abstract

A new catalytic asymmetric desymmetrization reaction for the synthesis of enantioenriched derivatives of 2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane, a key motif common to many alkaloids, has been developed. Employing a cyclohexanediamine-derived primary amine organocatalyst, a range of prochiral cyclohexanone derivatives possessing an α,β-unsaturated ester moiety linked to the 4-position afforded the bicyclic products, which possess three stereogenic centers, as single diastereoisomers in high enantioselectivity (83–99 % ee) and in good yields (60–90 %). Calculations revealed that stepwise CC bond formation and proton transfer via a chair-shaped transition state dictate the exclusive endo selectivity and enabled the development of a highly enantioselective primary amine catalyst.

Co-reporter:Luis Simón and Robert S. Paton
The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2015 Volume 80(Issue 5) pp:2756-2766
Publication Date(Web):February 6, 2015
DOI:10.1021/acs.joc.5b00063
We report a hybrid density functional theory–molecular mechanics study of the mechanism of the addition of nitroalkanes and phosphonates to benzaldehyde catalyzed by a chiral phosphacene catalyst developed by Ooi and co-workers. Our results are consistent with a reaction mechanism in which a catalyst molecule simultaneously interacts by hydrogen bonds with the nucleophile and the electrophile, transferring a proton to the aldehyde in concert with carbon–carbon bond formation. Despite the C2 symmetry of this class of organocatalyst, substrate recognition, and asymmetric induction in both reaction classes studied relies on interactions with nonequivalent N–H bonds that break symmetry. The origin of the stereo and diastereoselectivity is discussed in terms of steric effects and of the conformations adopted by the reactants, and the most favorable transition structure results from minimal geometric distortion energies. A rational model for predicting the major stereoisomer of reactions catalyzed by this chiral phosphacene, based on the qualitative assessment of steric interactions, is given.
Co-reporter:Kelvin E. Jackson, Claire L. Mortimer, Barbara Odell, Jeffrey M. McKenna, Timothy D. W. Claridge, Robert S. Paton, and David M. Hodgson
The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2015 Volume 80(Issue 20) pp:9838-9846
Publication Date(Web):September 24, 2015
DOI:10.1021/acs.joc.5b01804
1H NMR and computational analyses provide insight into the regiodivergent (α- and α′-) lithiation–electrophile trapping of N-thiopivaloyl- and N-(tert-butoxythiocarbonyl)-α-alkylazetidines. The magnitudes of the rotation barriers in these azetidines indicate that rotamer interconversions do not occur at the temperature and on the time scale of the lithiations. The NMR and computational studies support the origin of regioselectivity as being thiocarbonyl-directed lithiation from the lowest energy amide-like rotameric forms (cis for N-thiopivaloyl and trans for N-tert-butoxythiocarbonyl).
Co-reporter:Junbin Han;Zhichao Lu;Andrew L. Flach; Robert S. Paton; Gerald B. Hammond; Bo Xu
Chemistry - A European Journal 2015 Volume 21( Issue 33) pp:11687-11691
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201502407

Abstract

A hydrogen bond acceptor plays an important role in the catalytic cycle of organo-enamine catalysis. It can effectively influence the rate of reaction through hydrogen bonding interaction with enammonium (N-protonated enamine intermediate). Our findings are supported by both kinetic experiments and quantum chemical calculations.

Co-reporter:Wilian A. Cortopassi;Robert Simion;Charles E. Honsby; Tanos C. C. França; Robert S. Paton
Chemistry - A European Journal 2015 Volume 21( Issue 52) pp:
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201585201
Co-reporter:Hung V. Pham ; Robert S. Paton ; Audrey G. Ross ; Samuel J. Danishefsky ;K. N. Houk
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2014 Volume 136(Issue 6) pp:2397-2403
Publication Date(Web):January 13, 2014
DOI:10.1021/ja410220w
The intramolecular Diels–Alder reactions of cycloalkenones and terminal dienes occur with high endo stereoselectivity, both thermally and under Lewis-acidic conditions. Through computations, we show that steric repulsion and tether conformation govern the selectivity of the reaction, and incorporation of either BF3 or α-halogenation increases the rate of cycloaddition. With a longer tether, isomerization from a terminal diene to the more stable internal diene results in a more facile cycloaddition.
Co-reporter:Dr. Peter C. Knipe;Dr. Matija Gredi&x10d;ak;Artiom Cernijenko;Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Martin D. Smith
Chemistry - A European Journal 2014 Volume 20( Issue 11) pp:3005-3009
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201400192

Abstract

A cascade reaction that generates pyrrolo- and pyridoindoline motifs from isocyanide precursors under phase-transfer conditions is described. This transformation proceeds at room temperature in the presence of a quaternary ammonium catalyst and base to generate functionalized products containing an all-carbon quaternary stereocentre. Quantum chemical calculations demonstrated that intramolecular general acid catalysis plays a key accelerating role through stabilization of developing charge in the transition state, and that the reaction is best described as a 5-endo dig cyclization, rather than an anionic 6π electrocyclization. Investigations employing chiral phase-transfer catalysts have given promising selectivities to date.

Co-reporter:Seonah Kim;Jerry Ståhlberg;Mats Sandgren;Gregg T. Beckham;
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2014 111(1) pp:149-154
Publication Date(Web):December 16, 2013
DOI:10.1073/pnas.1316609111
Lytic polysaccharide monooxygenases (LPMOs) exhibit a mononuclear copper-containing active site and use dioxygen and a reducing agent to oxidatively cleave glycosidic linkages in polysaccharides. LPMOs represent a unique paradigm in carbohydrate turnover and exhibit synergy with hydrolytic enzymes in biomass depolymerization. To date, several features of copper binding to LPMOs have been elucidated, but the identity of the reactive oxygen species and the key steps in the oxidative mechanism have not been elucidated. Here, density functional theory calculations are used with an enzyme active site model to identify the reactive oxygen species and compare two hypothesized reaction pathways in LPMOs for hydrogen abstraction and polysaccharide hydroxylation; namely, a mechanism that employs a η1-superoxo intermediate, which abstracts a substrate hydrogen and a hydroperoxo species is responsible for substrate hydroxylation, and a mechanism wherein a copper-oxyl radical abstracts a hydrogen and subsequently hydroxylates the substrate via an oxygen-rebound mechanism. The results predict that oxygen binds end-on (η1) to copper, and that a copper-oxyl–mediated, oxygen-rebound mechanism is energetically preferred. The N-terminal histidine methylation is also examined, which is thought to modify the structure and reactivity of the enzyme. Density functional theory calculations suggest that this posttranslational modification has only a minor effect on the LPMO active site structure or reactivity for the examined steps. Overall, this study suggests the steps in the LPMO mechanism for oxidative cleavage of glycosidic bonds.
Co-reporter:Stephen C. Chmely, Seonah Kim, Peter N. Ciesielski, Gonzalo Jiménez-Osés, Robert S. Paton, and Gregg T. Beckham
ACS Catalysis 2013 Volume 3(Issue 5) pp:963
Publication Date(Web):April 2, 2013
DOI:10.1021/cs400110r
We employ density functional theory (DFT) calculations and kinetics measurements to understand the mechanism of a xantphos-containing molecular ruthenium catalyst acting on an alkyl aryl ether linkage similar to that found in lignin to produce acetophenone and phenol. The most favorable reaction pathway suggested from DFT is compared to kinetics measurements, and good agreement is found between the predicted and the measured activation barriers. The DFT calculations reveal several interesting features, including an unusual 5-membered transition state structure for oxidative insertion in contrast to the typically proposed 3-membered transition state, a preference for an O-bound over a C-bound Ru–enolate, and a significant kinetic preference for the order of product release from the catalyst. The experimental measurements confirm that the reaction proceeds via a free ketone intermediate, but also suggest that the conversion of the intermediate ketone to acetophenone and phenol does not necessarily require ketone dissociation from the catalyst. Overall, this work elucidates the kinetically and thermodynamically preferred reaction pathways for tandem alcohol dehydrogenation and reductive ether bond cleavage by the ruthenium-xantphos catalyst.Keywords: aryl-ether cleavage; dehydrogenation; lignin deconstruction; oxidative reduction; reductive elimination; Ru-xantphos
Co-reporter:David J. Shepherd;Dr. Phillip A. Broadwith;Dr. Bryony S. Dyson;Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Jonathan W. Burton
Chemistry - A European Journal 2013 Volume 19( Issue 38) pp:12644-12648
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201302349
Co-reporter:Dr. Filippo Sladojevich;Ángel L. FuentesdeArriba;Dr. Irene Ortín;Dr. Ting Yang;Dr. Alessro Ferrali;Dr. Robert S. Paton; Darren J. Dixon
Chemistry - A European Journal 2013 Volume 19( Issue 42) pp:14286-14295
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/chem.201200832

Abstract

The enantioselective Conia-ene cyclization of alkyne-tethered β-ketoesters is efficiently catalyzed by the combination of cinchona-derived amino-urea pre-catalysts and copper(I) salts. The reaction scope is broad and a series of substrates can be efficiently cyclized with high yields and enantioselectivities. Herein, we present a detailed mechanistic study based on experimental considerations and quantum mechanical calculations. Several variables, such as the nature of the organic pre-catalyst and the metal-ion source, have been thoroughly investigated. Kinetic studies, as well as kinetic isotope effects and deuterium labeling experiments have been used to gain further insights into the mechanism and prove the cooperative nature of the catalytic system. Our studies suggest that the rate-limiting step for the reaction involves the β-ketoester deprotonation and that the active species responsible for the enantiodeterming step is monomeric in amino-urea pre-catalyst. Computational studies provide a quantitative understanding of the observed stereoinduction and identify hydrogen bonding from the urea group as a crucial factor in determining the observed enantioselectivity.

Co-reporter:David M. Hodgson, Andrew Charlton, Robert S. Paton, and Amber L. Thompson
The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2013 Volume 78(Issue 4) pp:1508-1518
Publication Date(Web):January 29, 2013
DOI:10.1021/jo3025972
The synthesis and alkylation of chiral, nonracemic tropane- and homotropane-derived enamines is examined as an approach to enantioenriched α-alkylated aldehydes. The two bicyclic N auxiliaries, which differ by a single methylene group, give opposite senses of asymmetric induction on alkylation with EtI and provide modestly enantioenriched 2-ethylhexanal (following hydrolysis of the alkylated iminium). The observed stereoselectivity is supported by density functional studies of ethylation for both enamines.
Co-reporter:Lufeng Zou, Robert S. Paton, Albert Eschenmoser, Timothy R. Newhouse, Phil S. Baran, and K. N. Houk
The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2013 Volume 78(Issue 8) pp:4037-4048
Publication Date(Web):March 5, 2013
DOI:10.1021/jo400350v
The site selectivities and stereoselectivities of C–H oxidations of substituted cyclohexanes and trans-decalins by dimethyldioxirane (DMDO) were investigated computationally with quantum mechanical density functional theory (DFT). The multiconfiguration CASPT2 method was employed on model systems to establish the preferred mechanism and transition state geometry. The reaction pathway involving a rebound step is established to account for the retention of stereochemistry. The oxidation of sclareolide with dioxirane reagents is reported, including the oxidation by the in situ generated tBu-TFDO, a new dioxirane that better discriminates between C–H bonds on the basis of steric effects. The release of 1,3-diaxial strain in the transition state contributes to the site selectivity and enhanced equatorial C–H bond reactivity for tertiary C–H bonds, a result of the lowering of distortion energy. In addition to this strain release factor, steric and inductive effects contribute to the rates of C–H oxidation by dioxiranes.
Co-reporter:Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. John M. Brown
Angewandte Chemie 2012 Volume 124( Issue 42) pp:10598-10600
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/ange.201205417
Co-reporter:Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. John M. Brown
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2012 Volume 51( Issue 42) pp:10448-10450
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/anie.201205417
Co-reporter:Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Seonah Kim;Audrey G. Ross; Samuel J. Danishefsky; K. N. Houk
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2011 Volume 50( Issue 44) pp:10366-10368
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/anie.201103998
Co-reporter:Dr. Robert S. Paton;Dr. Seonah Kim;Audrey G. Ross; Samuel J. Danishefsky; K. N. Houk
Angewandte Chemie 2011 Volume 123( Issue 44) pp:10550-10552
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/ange.201103998
Co-reporter:Luis Simón and Robert S. Paton
Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry 2016 - vol. 14(Issue 11) pp:NaN3039-3039
Publication Date(Web):2016/01/26
DOI:10.1039/C6OB00045B
The mechanism for the spiroacetalization of enol-ethers 1 and 2 promoted by chiral phosphoric acid (CPA) catalyst (I) and by chiral imidodiphosphoric acid catalyst (II) has been investigated by QM/MM methods. The computed levels of enantioselectivity following exhaustive conformational analysis is in close agreement with the sense and magnitude of experimental results. Small substrates fit inside catalyst I to yield both enantiomers, in agreement with the absence of asymmetric induction for this reaction, while for catalyst II chiral discrimination between TS structures is possible. Unlike reactions catalysed by CPA or CPA derivatives in which steric effects and substrate distortion controls enantioselectivity, we show that chiral discrimination results from the restricted area and direction of possible hydrogen-bonding interactions with a more confined catalyst structure.
Co-reporter:Natthawat Semakul, Kelvin E. Jackson, Robert S. Paton and Tomislav Rovis
Chemical Science (2010-Present) 2017 - vol. 8(Issue 2) pp:NaN1020-1020
Publication Date(Web):2016/09/23
DOI:10.1039/C6SC02587K
The diastereoselective coupling of O-substituted arylhydroxamates and cyclopropenes mediated by Rh(III) catalysis was successfully developed. Through ligand development, the diastereoselectivity of this reaction was improved using a heptamethylindenyl (Ind*) ligand, which has been rationalized using quantum chemical calculations. In addition, the nature of the O-substituted ester of benzhydroxamic acid proved important for high diastereoselectivity. This transformation tolerates a variety of benzamides and cyclopropenes that furnish cyclopropa[c]dihydroisoquinolones with high diastereocontrol, which could then be easily transformed into synthetically useful building blocks for pharmaceuticals and bio-active molecules.
Co-reporter:Wilian A. Cortopassi, Kiran Kumar and Robert S. Paton
Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry 2016 - vol. 14(Issue 46) pp:NaN10938-10938
Publication Date(Web):2016/10/26
DOI:10.1039/C6OB02234K
CREBBP bromodomains, epigenetic “reader” proteins that recognize acetylated histone lysine residues, are a current target for cancer therapy. We show that experimental CREBBP binding affinities of small-molecules with aromatic or heteroaromatic functional groups are strongly influenced by a cation–π interaction with a positively charged arginine residue. For a series of fifteen 5-isoxazolylbenzimidazole derivatives, the strength of this non-covalent interaction is directly related to improvements in binding to CREBBP. The aromatic substituents’ inductive and resonance effects are not obviously correlated with observed structure and affinity relationships. In contrast, a coulombic electrostatic model can quantitatively predict the interaction strength. We have assessed different Molecular Mechanics (MM) and Quantum Mechanics (QM) descriptions of the protein–ligand interaction. Quantitative models for binding affinity were generated from: (1) Poisson Boltzmann Surface Area (MM-PBSA) and Generalized Born Surface Area (MM-GBSA) scoring functions that incorporated the entire ligand and (2) QM-complexation energies and (3) Electrostatic Potential Surface values (ESPs) that analyzed the varying aromatic group. A linear relationship between QM-computed ESP values is established for the cation–π interaction strength, and gives the best correlation (R2 = 0.84) with experimental binding affinities. This model also ranks ligand affinity most accurately (rs = 0.91) from the models tested. Consideration of the electrostatic potential in response to the local effects of substituents in addition to that of the aromatic ring is necessary to understand and describe the interaction with the cationic guanidinium ion. This leads to an improved understanding and the ability to quantitatively predict the magnitude of non-covalent interactions in the CREBBP active site.
Co-reporter:Qian Peng, Fernanda Duarte and Robert S. Paton
Chemical Society Reviews 2016 - vol. 45(Issue 22) pp:NaN6107-6107
Publication Date(Web):2016/09/12
DOI:10.1039/C6CS00573J
Advances in theory and processing power have established computation as a valuable interpretative and predictive tool in the discovery of new asymmetric catalysts. This tutorial review outlines the theory and practice of modeling stereoselective reactions. Recent examples illustrate how an understanding of the fundamental principles and the application of state-of-the-art computational methods may be used to gain mechanistic insight into organic and organometallic reactions. We highlight the emerging potential of this computational tool-box in providing meaningful predictions for the rational design of asymmetric catalysts. We present an accessible account of the field to encourage future synergy between computation and experiment.
Bicyclo[2.2.2]octanone, 3-methyl-