Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott;Matthew J. Fuchter
Chemical Society Reviews 2017 vol. 46(Issue 19) pp:5689-5700
Publication Date(Web):2017/10/02
DOI:10.1039/C7CS00154A
The past decade has seen the subject of transition metal-free catalytic hydrogenation develop incredibly rapidly, transforming from a largely hypothetical possibility to a well-established field that can be applied to the reduction of a diverse variety of functional groups under mild conditions. This remarkable change is principally attributable to the development of so-called ‘frustrated Lewis pairs’: unquenched combinations of bulky Lewis acids and bases whose dual reactivity can be exploited for the facile activation of otherwise inert chemical bonds. While a number of comprehensive reviews into frustrated Lewis pair chemistry have been published in recent years, this tutorial review aims to provide a focused guide to the development of efficient FLP hydrogenation catalysts, through identification and consideration of the key factors that govern their effectiveness. Following discussion of these factors, their importance will be illustrated using a case study from our own research, namely the development of FLP protocols for successful hydrogenation of aldehydes and ketones, and for related moisture-tolerant hydrogenation.
Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott;Matthew J. Fuchter
Chemical Society Reviews 2017 vol. 46(Issue 19) pp:5689-5700
Publication Date(Web):2017/10/02
DOI:10.1039/C7CS00154A
The past decade has seen the subject of transition metal-free catalytic hydrogenation develop incredibly rapidly, transforming from a largely hypothetical possibility to a well-established field that can be applied to the reduction of a diverse variety of functional groups under mild conditions. This remarkable change is principally attributable to the development of so-called ‘frustrated Lewis pairs’: unquenched combinations of bulky Lewis acids and bases whose dual reactivity can be exploited for the facile activation of otherwise inert chemical bonds. While a number of comprehensive reviews into frustrated Lewis pair chemistry have been published in recent years, this tutorial review aims to provide a focused guide to the development of efficient FLP hydrogenation catalysts, through identification and consideration of the key factors that govern their effectiveness. Following discussion of these factors, their importance will be illustrated using a case study from our own research, namely the development of FLP protocols for successful hydrogenation of aldehydes and ketones, and for related moisture-tolerant hydrogenation.
Co-reporter:Adam D. Piascik;Peter J. Hill;Andrew D. Crawford;Laurence R. Doyle;Jennifer C. Green
Chemical Communications 2017 vol. 53(Issue 54) pp:7657-7660
Publication Date(Web):2017/07/04
DOI:10.1039/C7CC04188H
The first cationic Fe silyldiazenido complexes, [Fe(PP)2(NN–SiMe3)]+[BArF4]− (PP = dmpe/depe), have been synthesised and thoroughly characterised. Computational studies show the compounds to be useful structural and electronic surrogates for the more elusive [Fe(PP)2(NN–H)]+, which are postulated intermediates in the H+/e− mediated fixation of N2 by Fe(PP)2(N2) species.
Co-reporter:Peter J. Hill, Laurence R. Doyle, Andrew D. Crawford, William K. Myers, and Andrew E. Ashley
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2016 Volume 138(Issue 41) pp:13521-13524
Publication Date(Web):October 4, 2016
DOI:10.1021/jacs.6b08802
The catalytic fixation of N2 by molecular Fe compounds is a rapidly developing field, yet thus far few complexes can effect this transformation, and none are selective for N2H4 production. Herein we report that the simple Fe(0) complex Fe(Et2PCH2CH2PEt2)2(N2) (1) is an efficient catalyst for the selective conversion of N2 (>25 molecules N2 fixed) into N2H4, attendant with the production of ca. one molecule of NH3. Notably, the reductant (CoCp*2) and acid (Ph2NH2OTf) used are considerably weaker than conventional chemical H+ and e– sources used in previous demonstrations of N2 turnover by synthetic Fe compounds. These results show that the direct catalytic conversion of N2 to the hydrazine oxidation state on molecular Fe complexes is viable and that the mechanism of NH3 formation by such systems may proceed via Fe–N2H4 intermediates.
Co-reporter:Laurence R. Doyle, Peter J. Hill, Gregory G. Wildgoose and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2016 vol. 45(Issue 18) pp:7550-7554
Publication Date(Web):05 Apr 2016
DOI:10.1039/C6DT00884D
The Fe(0) species Fe(N2)(dmpe)2 exists in equilibrium with the previously unreported dimer, [Fe(dmpe2)2(μ-N2)]. For the first time these complexes, alongside Fe(N2)(depe)2, are shown unambiguously to produce N2H4 and/or NH3 upon addition of triflic acid; for Fe(N2)(depe)2 this represents one of the highest electron conversion efficiencies for Fe complexes to date.
Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott, Trevor R. Simmons, Elliot J. Lawrence, Gregory G. Wildgoose, Matthew J. Fuchter, and Andrew E. Ashley
ACS Catalysis 2015 Volume 5(Issue 9) pp:5540
Publication Date(Web):August 17, 2015
DOI:10.1021/acscatal.5b01417
Despite rapid advances in the field of metal-free, “frustrated Lewis pair” (FLP)-catalyzed hydrogenation, the need for strictly anhydrous reaction conditions has hampered wide-scale uptake of this methodology. Herein, we report that, despite the generally perceived moisture sensitivity of FLPs, 1,4-dioxane solutions of B(C6F5)3 actually show appreciable moisture tolerance and can catalyze hydrogenation of a range of weakly basic substrates without the need for rigorously inert conditions. In particular, reactions can be performed directly in commercially available nonanhydrous solvents without subsequent drying or use of internal desiccants.Keywords: catalytic hydrogenation; metal-free; solvent effects; water tolerance; “frustrated Lewis pairs”
Co-reporter:Peter J. Hill, Thomas J. Herrington, Nicholas H. Rees, Andrew J. P. White and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2015 vol. 44(Issue 19) pp:8984-8992
Publication Date(Web):31 Mar 2015
DOI:10.1039/C5DT00821B
The electron-deficient and sterically bulky trialkylborane derivative tris[bis(pentafluorophenyl)methyl]borane [1, B(CH(C6F5)2)3], has been synthesised and comprehensively characterised; detailed 1H and 19F NMR studies reveal two dynamic bond rotational processes in the solution phase. Despite conventional probes (Gutmann–Beckett and Childs methods) implying that the compound has a very limited Lewis acidity, it was used to generate frustrated Lewis pairs capable of heterolytically activating H2 in ethereal solutions, which suggests that the hydridophilicity of 1 is comparable to the potent Lewis acid B(C6F5)3.
Co-reporter:Elliot J. Lawrence ; Vasily S. Oganesyan ; David L. Hughes ; Andrew E. Ashley ;Gregory G. Wildgoose
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2014 Volume 136(Issue 16) pp:6031-6036
Publication Date(Web):April 2, 2014
DOI:10.1021/ja500477g
Frustrated Lewis pairs have found many applications in the heterolytic activation of H2 and subsequent hydrogenation of small molecules through delivery of the resulting proton and hydride equivalents. Herein, we describe how H2 can be preactivated using classical frustrated Lewis pair chemistry and combined with in situ nonaqueous electrochemical oxidation of the resulting borohydride. Our approach allows hydrogen to be cleanly converted into two protons and two electrons in situ, and reduces the potential (the required energetic driving force) for nonaqueous H2 oxidation by 610 mV (117.7 kJ mol–1). This significant energy reduction opens routes to the development of nonaqueous hydrogen energy technology.
Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott ; Matthew J. Fuchter
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2014 Volume 136(Issue 45) pp:15813-15816
Publication Date(Web):October 21, 2014
DOI:10.1021/ja5088979
Solutions of the Lewis acid B(C6F5)3 in 1,4-dioxane are found to effectively catalyze the hydrogenation of a variety of ketones and aldehydes. These reactions, the first to allow entirely metal-free catalytic hydrogenation of carbonyl groups under relatively mild reaction conditions, are found to proceed via a “frustrated Lewis pair” mechanism in which the solvent, a weak Brønsted base yet moderately strong donor, plays a pivotal role.
Co-reporter:Thomas J. Herrington, Bryan J. Ward, Laurence R. Doyle, Joe McDermott, Andrew J. P. White, Patricia A. Hunt and Andrew E. Ashley
Chemical Communications 2014 vol. 50(Issue 84) pp:12753-12756
Publication Date(Web):26 Aug 2014
DOI:10.1039/C4CC05905K
The thermally robust silylium complex [iPr3Si–PtBu3]+[B(C6F5)4]− (1) activates H2/D2 at 90 °C (PhCl); no evidence for dissociation into the separated Lewis pair is found. DFT calculations show H2 cleavage proceeds via Si–P bond elongation to form an encounter complex directly from the adduct, thus avoiding the non-isolable iPr3Si+–PtBu3 FLP.
Co-reporter:Laurence R. Doyle;Alex Heath;Choon Heng Low
Advanced Synthesis & Catalysis 2014 Volume 356( Issue 2-3) pp:603-608
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/adsc.201300787
Co-reporter:Elliot J. Lawrence;Thomas J. Herrington;Dr. Andrew E. Ashley;Dr. Gregory G. Wildgoose
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2014 Volume 53( Issue 37) pp:9922-9925
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/anie.201405721
Abstract
In order to use H2 as a clean source of electricity, prohibitively rare and expensive precious metal electrocatalysts, such as Pt, are often used to overcome the large oxidative voltage required to convert H2 into 2 H+ and 2 e−. Herein, we report a metal-free approach to catalyze the oxidation of H2 by combining the ability of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) to heterolytically cleave H2 with the in situ electrochemical oxidation of the resulting borohydride. The use of the NHC-stabilized borenium cation [(IiPr2)(BC8H14)]+ (IiPr2=C3H2(NiPr)2, NHC=N-heterocyclic carbene) as the Lewis acidic component of the FLP is shown to decrease the voltage required for H2 oxidation by 910 mV at inexpensive carbon electrodes, a significant energy saving equivalent to 175.6 kJ mol−1. The NHC–borenium Lewis acid also offers improved catalyst recyclability and chemical stability compared to B(C6F5)3, the paradigm Lewis acid originally used to pioneer our combined electrochemical/frustrated Lewis pair approach.
Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott;Dr. Matthew J. Fuchter ;Dr. Andrew E. Ashley
Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2014 Volume 53( Issue 38) pp:10218-10222
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/anie.201405531
Abstract
In recent years ‘frustrated Lewis pairs’ (FLPs) have been shown to be effective metal-free catalysts for the hydrogenation of many unsaturated substrates. Even so, limited functional-group tolerance restricts the range of solvents in which FLP-mediated reactions can be performed, with all FLP-mediated hydrogenations reported to date carried out in non-donor hydrocarbon or chlorinated solvents. Herein we report that the bulky Lewis acids B(C6Cl5)x(C6F5)3−x (x=0–3) are capable of heterolytic H2 activation in the strong-donor solvent THF, in the absence of any additional Lewis base. This allows metal-free catalytic hydrogenations to be performed in donor solvent media under mild conditions; these systems are particularly effective for the hydrogenation of weakly basic substrates, including the first examples of metal-free catalytic hydrogenation of furan heterocycles. The air-stability of the most effective borane, B(C6Cl5)(C6F5)2, makes this a practically simple reaction method.
Co-reporter:Elliot J. Lawrence;Thomas J. Herrington;Dr. Andrew E. Ashley;Dr. Gregory G. Wildgoose
Angewandte Chemie 2014 Volume 126( Issue 37) pp:10080-10083
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/ange.201405721
Abstract
In order to use H2 as a clean source of electricity, prohibitively rare and expensive precious metal electrocatalysts, such as Pt, are often used to overcome the large oxidative voltage required to convert H2 into 2 H+ and 2 e−. Herein, we report a metal-free approach to catalyze the oxidation of H2 by combining the ability of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) to heterolytically cleave H2 with the in situ electrochemical oxidation of the resulting borohydride. The use of the NHC-stabilized borenium cation [(IiPr2)(BC8H14)]+ (IiPr2=C3H2(NiPr)2, NHC=N-heterocyclic carbene) as the Lewis acidic component of the FLP is shown to decrease the voltage required for H2 oxidation by 910 mV at inexpensive carbon electrodes, a significant energy saving equivalent to 175.6 kJ mol−1. The NHC–borenium Lewis acid also offers improved catalyst recyclability and chemical stability compared to B(C6F5)3, the paradigm Lewis acid originally used to pioneer our combined electrochemical/frustrated Lewis pair approach.
Co-reporter:Daniel J. Scott;Dr. Matthew J. Fuchter ;Dr. Andrew E. Ashley
Angewandte Chemie 2014 Volume 126( Issue 38) pp:10382-10386
Publication Date(Web):
DOI:10.1002/ange.201405531
Abstract
In recent years ‘frustrated Lewis pairs’ (FLPs) have been shown to be effective metal-free catalysts for the hydrogenation of many unsaturated substrates. Even so, limited functional-group tolerance restricts the range of solvents in which FLP-mediated reactions can be performed, with all FLP-mediated hydrogenations reported to date carried out in non-donor hydrocarbon or chlorinated solvents. Herein we report that the bulky Lewis acids B(C6Cl5)x(C6F5)3−x (x=0–3) are capable of heterolytic H2 activation in the strong-donor solvent THF, in the absence of any additional Lewis base. This allows metal-free catalytic hydrogenations to be performed in donor solvent media under mild conditions; these systems are particularly effective for the hydrogenation of weakly basic substrates, including the first examples of metal-free catalytic hydrogenation of furan heterocycles. The air-stability of the most effective borane, B(C6Cl5)(C6F5)2, makes this a practically simple reaction method.
Co-reporter:Hasna Zaher, Andrew E. Ashley, Mark Irwin, Amber L. Thompson, Matthias J. Gutmann, Tobias Krämer and Dermot O'Hare
Chemical Communications 2013 vol. 49(Issue 84) pp:9755-9757
Publication Date(Web):16 Sep 2013
DOI:10.1039/C3CC45889J
The product of the intermolecular ‘frustrated Lewis pair’ (FLP) B(C6F5)2(C6Cl5)/2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine and H2 has been studied by single-crystal neutron diffraction. This is the first structurally characterised example of a geometrically unconstrained dihydrogen (H⋯H) bond within a hydrogenated FLP system.
Co-reporter:Thomas J. Herrington, Alex J. W. Thom, Andrew J. P. White and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2012 vol. 41(Issue 30) pp:9019-9022
Publication Date(Web):17 Apr 2012
DOI:10.1039/C2DT30384A
Tris[3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl]borane (1, BArF18), has been synthesised on a practical scale for the first time. According to the Gutmann–Beckett method it is a more powerful Lewis acid than B(C6F5)3. It forms a ‘frustrated Lewis pair’ with 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine which cleaves H2 to form a salt containing the novel anion [μ-H(BArF18)2]−.
Co-reporter:Andrew E. Ashley ; Thomas J. Herrington ; Gregory G. Wildgoose ; Hasna Zaher ; Amber L. Thompson ; Nicholas H. Rees ; Tobias Krämer ;Dermot O’Hare
Journal of the American Chemical Society 2011 Volume 133(Issue 37) pp:14727-14740
Publication Date(Web):July 25, 2011
DOI:10.1021/ja205037t
A new family of electron-deficient tris(aryl)boranes, B(C6F5)3–n(C6Cl5)n (n = 1–3), has been synthesized, permitting an investigation into the steric and electronic effects resulting from the gradual replacement of C6F5 with C6Cl5 ligands. B(C6F5)2(C6Cl5) (3) is accessed via C6Cl5BBr2, itself prepared from donor-free Zn(C6Cl5)2 and BBr3. Reaction of C6Cl5Li with BCl3 in a Et2O/hexane slurry selectively produced B(C6Cl5)2Cl, which undergoes B–Cl exchange with CuC6F5 to afford B(C6F5)(C6Cl5)2 (5). While 3 forms a complex with H2O, which can be rapidly removed under vacuum or in the presence of molecular sieves, B(C6Cl5)3 (6) is completely stable to refluxing toluene/H2O for several days. Compounds 3, 5, and 6 have been structurally characterized using single crystal X-ray diffraction and represent the first structure determinations for compounds featuring B–C6Cl5 bonds; each exhibits a trigonal planar geometry about B, despite having different ligand sets. The spectroscopic characterization using 11B, 19F, and 13C NMR indicates that the boron center becomes more electron-deficient as n increases. Optimized structures of B(C6F5)3–n(C6Cl5)n (n = 0–3) using density functional theory (B3LYP/TZVP) are all fully consistent with the experimental structural data. Computed 11B shielding constants also replicate the experimental trend almost quantitatively, and the computed natural charges on the boron center increase in the order n = 0 (0.81) < n = 1 (0.89) < n = 2 (1.02) < n = 3 (1.16), supporting the hypothesis that electrophilicity increases concomitantly with substitution of C6F5 for C6Cl5. The direct solution cyclic voltammetry of B(C6F5)3 has been obtained for the first time and electrochemical measurements upon the entire series B(C6F5)3–n(C6Cl5)n (n = 0–3) corroborate the spectroscopic data, revealing C6Cl5 to be a more electron-withdrawing group than C6F5, with a ca. +200 mV shift observed in the reduction potential per C6F5 group replaced. Conversely, use of the Guttmann-Beckett and Childs’ methods to determine Lewis acidity on B(C6F5)3, 3, and 5 showed this property to diminish with increasing C6Cl5 content, which is attributed to the steric effects of the bulky C6Cl5 substituents. This conflict is ascribed to the minimal structural reorganization in the radical anions upon reduction during cyclic voltammetric experiments. Reduction of 6 using Na(s) in THF results in a vivid blue paramagnetic solution of Na+ [6]•–; the EPR signal of Na+[6]•– is centered at g = 2.002 with a(11B) 10G. Measurements of the exponential decay of the EPR signal (298 K) reveal [6]•– to be considerably more stable than its perfluoro analogue.
Co-reporter:Thomas J. Herrington, Bryan J. Ward, Laurence R. Doyle, Joe McDermott, Andrew J. P. White, Patricia A. Hunt and Andrew E. Ashley
Chemical Communications 2014 - vol. 50(Issue 84) pp:NaN12756-12756
Publication Date(Web):2014/08/26
DOI:10.1039/C4CC05905K
The thermally robust silylium complex [iPr3Si–PtBu3]+[B(C6F5)4]− (1) activates H2/D2 at 90 °C (PhCl); no evidence for dissociation into the separated Lewis pair is found. DFT calculations show H2 cleavage proceeds via Si–P bond elongation to form an encounter complex directly from the adduct, thus avoiding the non-isolable iPr3Si+–PtBu3 FLP.
Co-reporter:Laurence R. Doyle, Peter J. Hill, Gregory G. Wildgoose and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2016 - vol. 45(Issue 18) pp:NaN7554-7554
Publication Date(Web):2016/04/05
DOI:10.1039/C6DT00884D
The Fe(0) species Fe(N2)(dmpe)2 exists in equilibrium with the previously unreported dimer, [Fe(dmpe2)2(μ-N2)]. For the first time these complexes, alongside Fe(N2)(depe)2, are shown unambiguously to produce N2H4 and/or NH3 upon addition of triflic acid; for Fe(N2)(depe)2 this represents one of the highest electron conversion efficiencies for Fe complexes to date.
Co-reporter:Adam D. Piascik, Peter J. Hill, Andrew D. Crawford, Laurence R. Doyle, Jennifer C. Green and Andrew E. Ashley
Chemical Communications 2017 - vol. 53(Issue 54) pp:NaN7660-7660
Publication Date(Web):2017/06/19
DOI:10.1039/C7CC04188H
The first cationic Fe silyldiazenido complexes, [Fe(PP)2(NN–SiMe3)]+[BArF4]− (PP = dmpe/depe), have been synthesised and thoroughly characterised. Computational studies show the compounds to be useful structural and electronic surrogates for the more elusive [Fe(PP)2(NN–H)]+, which are postulated intermediates in the H+/e− mediated fixation of N2 by Fe(PP)2(N2) species.
Co-reporter:Hasna Zaher, Andrew E. Ashley, Mark Irwin, Amber L. Thompson, Matthias J. Gutmann, Tobias Krämer and Dermot O'Hare
Chemical Communications 2013 - vol. 49(Issue 84) pp:NaN9757-9757
Publication Date(Web):2013/09/16
DOI:10.1039/C3CC45889J
The product of the intermolecular ‘frustrated Lewis pair’ (FLP) B(C6F5)2(C6Cl5)/2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine and H2 has been studied by single-crystal neutron diffraction. This is the first structurally characterised example of a geometrically unconstrained dihydrogen (H⋯H) bond within a hydrogenated FLP system.
Co-reporter:Peter J. Hill, Thomas J. Herrington, Nicholas H. Rees, Andrew J. P. White and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2015 - vol. 44(Issue 19) pp:NaN8992-8992
Publication Date(Web):2015/03/31
DOI:10.1039/C5DT00821B
The electron-deficient and sterically bulky trialkylborane derivative tris[bis(pentafluorophenyl)methyl]borane [1, B(CH(C6F5)2)3], has been synthesised and comprehensively characterised; detailed 1H and 19F NMR studies reveal two dynamic bond rotational processes in the solution phase. Despite conventional probes (Gutmann–Beckett and Childs methods) implying that the compound has a very limited Lewis acidity, it was used to generate frustrated Lewis pairs capable of heterolytically activating H2 in ethereal solutions, which suggests that the hydridophilicity of 1 is comparable to the potent Lewis acid B(C6F5)3.
Co-reporter:Thomas J. Herrington, Alex J. W. Thom, Andrew J. P. White and Andrew E. Ashley
Dalton Transactions 2012 - vol. 41(Issue 30) pp:NaN9022-9022
Publication Date(Web):2012/04/17
DOI:10.1039/C2DT30384A
Tris[3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl]borane (1, BArF18), has been synthesised on a practical scale for the first time. According to the Gutmann–Beckett method it is a more powerful Lewis acid than B(C6F5)3. It forms a ‘frustrated Lewis pair’ with 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine which cleaves H2 to form a salt containing the novel anion [μ-H(BArF18)2]−.